Are prices always right? The theory that markets instantly reflect all available information.
The Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH), associated with Eugene Fama, holds that asset prices fully reflect all available information. If true, it is impossible to consistently beat the market by trading on that information—prices already incorporate it. The EMH is the intellectual foundation of passive, index-based investing.
Weak form: Prices reflect all past price data. Technical analysis—predicting future prices from past patterns—cannot systematically generate excess returns.
Semi-strong form: Prices reflect all publicly available information (financials, news). Fundamental analysis of public data cannot consistently beat the market, because prices adjust almost instantly to new public disclosures.
Strong form: Prices reflect all information, including private and insider information. No one—even insiders—can reliably beat the market.
Supporting: The overwhelming majority of actively managed funds fail to beat low-cost index funds over long periods— consistent with prices already being efficient.
Anomalies: Seasonal effects, value and momentum premiums, and post-earnings drift suggest systematic patterns inconsistent with full efficiency.
Behavioral finance: Psychological biases (see Overconfidence Bias, Mental Accounting) lead to mispricing that efficient markets would rule out.
Indexing works: Even if markets aren’t perfectly efficient, they are hard to beat after costs—so diversified, low-cost index funds beat most active managers.
Insider trading is illegal: The strong form’s most extreme claim is precisely why insider trading is prohibited— information advantage would let insiders profit unfairly.
A lively debate: The EMH is one of finance’s most contested ideas, dividing believers in market efficiency from behavioral economists who see persistent, exploitable mistakes (see Behavioral Finance).